Todd L. Savitt research collection
Scope and Contents
This collection consists of physical and digital research materials compiled by Todd L. Savitt, PhD., related to the topic of medical practices in Montana, particularly related to Dr. Edwin S. Kellogg, abortions, Dr. Charles A. McNulty, and the State Board of Medical Examiners and their licensure. This collection consists primarily of subject files. The majority of the physical portion of this collection is photocopied. The date range of physical material (1860-2018) reflects the original creation dates, not the photocopy creation dates. The physical portion of this collection includes handwritten and transcribed correspondence, such as that of Elizabeth "Lizzy" Fisk, Flora McNulty and McNulty’s patients, scholarly articles, death records, annual reports, directories, court case documents and transcripts - including an abortion case related to Adeline Bromley, a Black woman living in Helena - photographs, estate records, genealogical records, newspaper clippings, research notes and email correspondence between Savitt and other professionals or repositories.
Some of the original material resides at the Montana Historical Society. Please see the "Related Materials" section for links to those finding aids. The Diane Sands collection material is housed at University of Montana's Archives and Special Collections, Mansfield Library.
The digital portion of this collection also consists of research materials gathered by Savitt on the same topics of Kellogg, McNulty, the Board of Medical Examiners and general medical practice in Montana at the turn of the 20th century, as well as Savitt’s original writings, revisions and presentations on the same topics. Additionally, charts related to data on the Board of Medical Examiners and practitioners compiled by Savitt are included. The date range (2004-2021) reflects modified dates, not necessarily creation dates. Represented formats include .pdf, .xlsx, .doc, .ppt, .jpg, .bmp, .rtf, and .tif.
Dates
- Creation: 1860-2021
Language of Materials
English
Conditions Governing Access
Collection open for research. The Montana Historical Society does not own the copyright on most of this material. As such, we cannot provide unrestricted online access to all materials. If you would like to access the digital files, please contact an archivist.
Conditions Governing Use
The Montana Historical Society does not own the copyright on most of this material. As such, we cannot provide unrestricted online access to all materials. If you would like to access the digital files, please contact an archivist.
Researchers must use collection in accordance with the policies of the Montana Historical Society Library & Archives. The Library & Archives does not necessarily hold copyright to all materials in the collection. In some cases permission for use may require additional authorization from the copyright owners. For more information contact an archivist.
Historical Note
Todd L. Savitt, PhD, was born in 1943 and is a historian of medicine and medical practice, particularly pertaining to African American medical history and American West medical history. He has many numerous articles, including those on the topic of E.S. Kellogg and C.A. McNulty, with works appearing in Montana: The Magazine of Western History in 2003, 2007, 2016, 2017 and 2020.
This research collection primarily pertains to Edwin S. Kellogg and Charles A. McNulty.
Edwin S. Kellogg was born in Worcester, Massachusetts in 1850. He completed his medical education at Dartmouth College and two other homeopathic schools, before serving as county physician in Walla Walla, Washington Territory. He moved to Helena, Montana Territory in 1884. In Helena, he was involved in several legal cases, mostly related to or involving the performance of abortions, and had a reputation in the community as an abortionist, even though it was illegal to perform or to receive an abortion in Montana. Some of the most notable Kellogg trials include the 1893 "Case of the Headless Fetus", the 1900 Sophie Hrella Case, the 1900 Adeline Bromley Case, and the 1914-1915 Lydia Johnson Case. The State Board of Medical Examiners also at times revoked his medical license and pursued legal charges against him, such as unprofessional conduct and practicing without a license. He was never convicted in any abortion-related trials. Kellogg died in Helena shortly after the Lydia Johnson Case in 1915. He is buried in Forestvale Cemetery in Helena, Montana.
Charles A. McNulty was born in Bellevue, Iowa in 1855, to Arabella and George W. McNulty. By 1879, he was studying dentistry in Butte, Montana. He married Flora McKay in 1884. Prior to their marriage, Flora received a bachelor’s degree in medical studies from Iowa College in 1883. As newlyweds they moved frequently throughout Montana, in part due to the inconsistent nature of a frontier dentistry practice. Both Charles and Flora attended the University of Colorado Medical Department to pursue further medical training, then finished their degrees in Chicago. In 1887, the McNultys established a medical and dental practice in Virginia City. Despite her accreditation, Flora was never a practicing physician. The practice experienced instability due to competition within the small town. The rural landscape meant most of McNulty's business consisted of house calls. In 1894, McNulty successfully ran for the Madison County coroner position. In this role, he oversaw the inquest of the shooting of William Ennis and testified in the subsequent 1898 murder trial. In 1899, McNulty left the Virginia City area and frequently traveled for the remainder of his life. Flora and Charles were formally divorced in 1900. Charles committed suicide in Harlem, Montana in 1904.
Extent
3.2 linear ft
724.4 Megabytes (571 Computer files)
Abstract
This collection includes physical and digital research materials compiled by Todd L. Savitt, PhD. His research is centered around Montana medical and abortion history, particularly related to the practices of Edwin S. Kellogg, Charles A. McNulty, and the State Board of Medical Examiners. The majority of physical material within this collection is photocopied. The date range of physical material (1860-2018) reflects the original creation dates, not the photocopy creation dates. The date range for digital material (2004-2021) reflects the modified date. Both physical and digital material includes reproductions of handwritten and transcribed correspondence, scholarly articles, death records and statistics, annual reports, directories, court case documents and transcripts, photographs, estate records, genealogical records, newspaper clippings, research notes, article drafts, original presentations, and email correspondence between Savitt and other professionals or repositories.
Arrangement
This collection is arranged into three subgroups: 1) Dr. Edwin S. Kellogg, 2) Dr. Charles A. McNulty, and 3) Medical Licensure and Practice. Series are organized alphabetically within subgroup. Subgroups 1 and 2 contain four series: Digital Presentations, Digital Subject Files, Digital Writings, and Subject Files (non-digital). Subgroup 3 contains three series: Digital Subject Files, Digital Writings, and Subject Files (non-digital).
Physical Location
Collection location TBD
Immediate Source of Acquisition
Acquisition information available upon request.
- Title
- Guide to the Todd L. Savitt Research Collection1860-2018
- Author
- Finding aid prepared by Tabitha Masters
- Date
- 2025
- Description rules
- Finding Aid Based On Dacs (Describing Archives: A Content Standard, 2nd Edition)
- Language of description
- English
- Script of description
- Latn
- Language of description note
- Finding aid written in English.
Repository Details
Part of the Montana Historical Society, Research Center Archives Repository
225 North Roberts
PO Box 201201
Helena MT 59620-1201 United States
406-444-2681
406-444-2696 (Fax)
mhslibrary@mt.gov